NBA

NBA PM: Making Sense of the Lance Stephenson Trade

lance_stephenson_hornets_2014_4

On Monday, the Los Angeles Clippers agreed to tradeย Matt Barnes and Spencer Hawes to the Charlotte Hornets in exchange for Lance Stephenson. It was a trade that includedย two of the more disappointing free agent signings from last summer.

After playing at a borderline All-Star level in 2013-14 with the Indiana Pacers, Stephenson signed with the Charlotte Hornets to help them take the next step in their development. In Stephenson, the Hornets were adding a 24-year-old swingman who could handle the ball and play stingy defense. The biggest concern with Stephenson is the fact that he is a hard personality to deal with. He has been described as โ€œtemperamentalโ€ and has had numerous on-court issues in the past. It was a worthwhile gamble at the time for the Hornets, even though the relationship ultimately didn’t workย out.

For the Clippers, in trading for Stephenson they are takingย the same sort of gamble that the Hornets tookย last offseason, only this time there are even more concerns. In his final season with the Indiana Pacers, Stephenson averaged 13.8 points, 4.5 assists and 7.2 rebounds per game, while shooting 49.1 percent from the field and 35.2 percent beyond-the-arc. He was a versatile two-way player that showed a developing game. However, in his one season with the Hornets, Stephenson averaged just 8.2 points, 3.9 assists and 4.5 rebounds, while shooting 37.6 percent from the field and 17.1 percent from three-point range.

There were a lot of factors that went into Stephensonโ€™s drop-off. Entering the season he injured his groin, and never fit within the Hornetโ€™s offensive schemes. He couldnโ€™t knock down three-pointers* and his inability to consistently hit shots off the dribble made it difficult to play him heavy minutes.

*Stephenson went 18-105 from beyond-the-arc, setting a new record for worst three-point percentage in a season with a minimum of 100 three-point attempts.

So why wouldย Doc Rivers, the Clippers head coach and team president, swing a trade for Stephenson after his steep decline?

First, the Clippers have been looking for young, athletic and productive wing players for several years now. Relying on J.J. Redick, Jamal Crawford, Austin Rivers and Matt Barnes was not a tenable situation if the Clippers want to make a deeper playoff run next season. Los Angeles has gotten by with Matt Barnes as their starting small forward for three years now, but he is now 35 years old and could see a major decline moving forward.

However, it should be noted that the Clippers didnโ€™t give up nothing for Stephenson. As bad as Hawes was in his one and only season with the Clippers, there was reason to believe he could bounce back next season. At his best, Hawes could have been the Clippersโ€™ third big (assuming they successfully re-sign DeAndre Jordan this offseason), and could provide spacing as a stretch-4 with his shooting. And as much criticism as Barnes received, he was in many ways exactly what the Clippers needed at small forward in the starting lineup.

Consider that last season, the Clippersโ€™ starting lineup was one of the best in the NBA:

Starting Unit

Chart Courtesy of NBA.com/stats

As we can see in this chart, the Clippers’ starting unit was the most efficient offensive lineup in the NBA and had a top three net differential (among all lineups that played 300 minutes or more together throughout the regular season). The Clippers couldnโ€™t have managed this if Barnes was a complete stiff, as some people have characterizedย him. Barnes was able to do this with above average perimeter defense, timely cuts to the basket, easy baskets in transition and by knocking down catch and shoot three-pointers.

Matt Barnes 2014-15 Shooting Chart

As we can see from the chart above, Barnes made a living with three-pointers and shots at the basket. While itโ€™s not particularly easy to find a competent 3-and-D wing player to fill this role, it still is a role that can be addressed with minimal financial flexibility.

The Clippers have reportedly shown interest in Wesley Johnson, who played with the Los Angeles Lakers this past season. Johnson has never lived up to the expectations that came with being selected fourth overall in the 2010 NBA Draft (one pick ahead of DeMarcus Cousins), but at the league-minimum, he has value. He may not be a lock-down defender, but he has the size, length and athleticism to be competitive. And on offense, he has shown that he could potentially take over Barnes’ role on offense.

Wesley Johnson 2014-15 Shooting Chart

Shot Charts Courtesy ofย www.austinclemens.com/shotcharts/

As we see here, Johnson shot pretty well from three-point range this last season, almost as good as Barnes. The difference is that in Byron Scottโ€™s offense (which features a heavy dose of mid-range jumpers), Johnson was shooting the ball from all over the court. This is contrary to the modern approach with players like Johnson, who are often positioned to takeย open, set jumpers, and attackย the rim against rotating defenses.

Put Johnson in Barnesโ€™ role, and we could see hisย shooting percentages climb and overall efficiency increase. If that happened, suddenly that potent offensive unit the Clippers had with Barnes could remain somewhatย intact. Another positive in adding Johnson is the fact that he’s still just 27 years old, so there is room for him to continue improving. That, and he would move from an offense that was being run by Jeremy Lin, Jordan Clarkson and Ronnie Price, to an offense run by Paul and Griffin, who are both able to consistently generate open looks for teammates. The factย that Johnson had a 52.7ย effective field goal percentage* on spot up jumpers last season (74.6 percentile), whereas Barnes had a 51.5 effective field goal percentage (64.8 percentile) provides more reason to believe he could be a competent replacement for Barnes.

*Among players that took two or more spot up jumpers per game.

Of course, we never know how effective a player will be with a new team in a new system until the players take the court. It’s also unclearย whether a player like Johnson (who will certainly be looking for a multi-year deal) would be open to a veteran’s minimum contract at this point in his career. But Johnson is simply representative of the sort of player the Clippersย could target to take over for Barnes.

Another such option, as discussed by our Alex Kennedy and Moke Hamilton on Tuesdayโ€™s Insider Sports Podcast, could be adding Paul Pierce with the mini mid-level exception (if he opts out of his deal with the Washington Wizards). In that scenario, the small forward role would need to be redefined in the Clippersโ€™ offense since Pierce is more than a spot up three-point shooter.

The main point here is that the starting small forward position can be filled with a competent player, which allows Stephenson to take a lead role in the second unit, which Rivers alluded to in his interview onย Tuesday withย Fred Roggin on the Beast 980 AM in Los Angeles.

In the playoffs, the Clippers relied on Austin Rivers and Jamal Crawford to be the primary ball-handlers off the bench. While Rivers had impressive spurts throughout the postseason, it is less than ideal to peg him as the lead guard off the bench moving forward. This is where Stephenson comes in.

Part of Stephensonโ€™s struggles last season came from the fact that he was sharing the court with Kemba Walker, a ball-dominant, scoring point guard. In the Clippersโ€™ second unit, he wonโ€™t have to share the ball with Chris Paul and can facilitate the offense as the primary playmaker.

How Stephenson fits is anyoneโ€™s guess since Rivers said he will playย anything from point guard, to shooting guard, to small forward for the Clippers. But considering how successful Stephenson was with a playmaking role in Indiana, how ineffective he was playing off the ball with Walker, and his spotty three-point shooting, the smart money is on Stephenson running the offense a lot when Paul is resting. His creativity off the dribble and large frame gives the Clippers an offensive weapon that was missing this last season, which in part explains why the Clippers’ bench was so ineffective.

In addition to being the lead guard off the bench, Stephenson also gives the Clippers a viable defensive option against the leagueโ€™s best perimeter scorers. Barnes has been the Clippers best and only option against players like Kevin Durant, LeBron James, Carmelo Anthony, Kawhi Leonard and Jimmy Butler, which is less than ideal to say the least.

โ€œWe needed to get tougher and we needed to get more athleticism and we needed to improve defensively,โ€ Rivers told Roggin.ย โ€œLance has shown he can do that for us. โ€ฆ Heโ€™s a tough kid, veryย competitive kid and that has gotten him in trouble at times, but the one thing he has shown in major playoff games is that he can be a top-tier defender.โ€

Barnes was scrappy and always put up a good effort, but he has lost a step in recent seasons and couldnโ€™t offer the defensive presence that guys like Leonard, Butler and Stephenson can. This is one of the main reasons Hornets owner Michael Jordan signed Stephenson last offseason.

“One of the reasons why I admire his game is he takes on challenges,” Jordan said last October. “For us to get any place in the East, we need someone to challenge LeBron. He challenged LeBron.”

If the Clippers plan on making it to the NBA Finals next season, having someone like Stephenson, who isnโ€™t afraid of going toe-to-toe with an opponentย as dominant as James, could be key. No one really stops a player like James,ย butย standing 6โ€™5 with a 6โ€™10 wingspan, Stephenson has as good of a chance as some of the better defenders in the league and certainly a better chance than Barnes.

Also, the Clippers simply need more talent. The Western Conference doesnโ€™t figure to be any easier next season, so the chance to add a player as versatile as Stephenson on a team-friendly contract was a unique opportunity that Rivers couldnโ€™t pass up.

โ€œThe team that gets the best player in the trade gets the best trade,โ€ Rivers said. โ€œAnd in this case, I think Lance is the best player in this trade.โ€

Stephenson was so bad in his one season in Charlotte that we forget just how good he can be when he is focused and in the right environment.

Triple Doubles Over Last Five Seasons

Graph Courtesy ofย www.statmuse.com/nba

As illustrated in the graph above, overย the last five seasons, Stephenson is in a four-way tie for the sixth most regular season triple doubles, all of which came in 2013-14. To add a player capable of that, before he enters his prime, is a pretty solid addition (albeit risky in the case of Stephenson because of chemistry concerns), especially when you consider his contract.

โ€œIf Lance works out, great,โ€ Rivers said. โ€œIf he doesnโ€™t, itโ€™s a one-year deal. I just like contractually where it went for us.โ€

In making this trade, the Clippers get out from under Hawesโ€™ contract, which has him earning roughly $18.5 million over the next three seasons. With Stephenson, the Clippers have a team option for 2015-16, which they can decline if he doesnโ€™t fit well with the team. And by having that option, the Clippers can also move Stephenson mid-season to a team that is looking to offload more salary heading into the 2016 free agency season.

Rivers is certainly responsible for putting the Clippersโ€™ in a position where this sort of high-risk, high-reward move is their only real option for improving. However, this deal is certainly a creative improvement over sending away a competent wing player and a first-round draft pick just to offload salary and avoid the apron (which is what Rivers did with Jared Dudley). In this move, Rivers lands a player that fills a big need, while adding financial flexibility. There is reason to be skeptical, or flat out critical of this trade, but this is a step in the right direction for Rivers as a general manager.

This deal wouldnโ€™t have been made if Rivers wasnโ€™t confident he can help Stephenson find his old game. Rivers has been an expert at managing personalities throughout his coaching career (see Rajon Rondo), though Stephenson may be his biggest challenge yet.

In eight months, we may be looking at this deal as a coup or a disaster for the Clippers. But at this moment, with little financial flexibility, an aging Chris Paul and a roster in need of more talent, it is the sort of high-upside deal the Clippers needed to make.

Author photo
Jeff Hawkins
Sports Editor

Jeff Hawkins is an award-winning sportswriter with more than four decades in the industry (print and digital media). A freelance writer/stay-at-home dad since 2008, Hawkins started his career with newspaper stints in Michigan, North Carolina, Florida, Upstate New York and Illinois, where he earned the 2004 APSE first-place award for column writing (under 40,000 circulation). As a beat writer, he covered NASCAR Winston Cup events at NHIS (1999-2003), the NHL's Chicago Blackhawks (2003-06) and the NFL's Carolina Panthers (2011-12). Hawkins penned four youth sports books, including a Michael Jordan biography. Hawkins' main hobbies include mountain bike riding, 5k trail runs at the Whitewater Center in Charlotte, N.C., and live music.

All posts by Jeff Hawkins
Author photo
Jeff Hawkins Sports Editor

Jeff Hawkins is an award-winning sportswriter with more than four decades in the industry (print and digital media). A freelance writer/stay-at-home dad since 2008, Hawkins started his career with newspaper stints in Michigan, North Carolina, Florida, Upstate New York and Illinois, where he earned the 2004 APSE first-place award for column writing (under 40,000 circulation). As a beat writer, he covered NASCAR Winston Cup events at NHIS (1999-2003), the NHL's Chicago Blackhawks (2003-06) and the NFL's Carolina Panthers (2011-12). Hawkins penned four youth sports books, including a Michael Jordan biography. Hawkins' main hobbies include mountain bike riding, 5k trail runs at the Whitewater Center in Charlotte, N.C., and live music.

All posts by Jeff Hawkins